Mobile vs. Landline In Disaster Recovery
Wednesday, August 30th, 2006
On the one year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina’s disastrous landfall on New Orleans and neighboring cities I find it suitable to call to your attention an article posted in Fierce Wireless about an on going debate amid an FCC request for comment on a panel’s recommendations after reviewing Hurricane Katrina’s impact on communications networks.
Apparently, the wireless operators want dibs when it comes to restoring power because cell phones have become a lifeline for many in the wake of natural disasters and emergencies. I also seem to remember friends of mine from New Orleans telling me that before they saw any FEMA or Aid trucks directly after the storm… the first tracks they saw were those of Cingular and Verizon providing temporary cell signals and repairing damaged towers.
Anyways, you see, the problem is that the situation really is that the wireless companies really are at the mercy of power and landline companies who hold the necessary infrastructure to restore power to cell sites and they are saying now way. I hope that is not just a jealousy play over cell phones stealing landline business.
In an FCC filing, AT&T said it’s unclear why wireless carriers should get priority over “tens of millions of other business and residential subscribers.” Verizon Communications says it opposes mandates that would “limit flexibility” of its response. While it does look like mobile-phone companies are trying to “muscle their way to the head of the line” of power restoration ahead of landline companies, as AT&T puts it, operators do have a point. Time after time we’ve seen people trying to rely on the mobile phones amid an emergency. One year after Hurricane Katrina hit, parts of New Orleans still don’t have landline service! Unfortunately, business interests and politics will play a starring role in the outcome of this one.
What I think. Well I have not seen all the data but from what I know the very fact that the places that have landline service would not be occupied immediately and the fact that most people would have evacuated in an emergency situation and be on the go (even when they get back), it might be a good idea to get the cell phones up and running. Also the fact that cell phones were somewhat usable during the actual storm (some people got camera phone shots and SMS’ out to friends) means that, it would appear, that at the very least SMS and other mobile services are more reliable than landline’s to begin with. I welcome your comments
For more on Cell Phones and Emergency Situations Click Here
Technorati Tags: emergencies, katrina, landline, wireless









